Richard Muscio Criticizes the CPA Profession for Granting Itself the Moniker “Most Trusted Advisor”

Significant literature exists in the CPA profession, whereby the CPA profession has granted itself the lofty title of “Most Trusted Advisor.” Witness the AICPA’s report “CPA Horizons 2025” and articles that have followed the release of this report.

The self-granting of this moniker to CPAs, by the CPA profession, is ludicrous.

This title has been self-conferred in comparison to other professional service disciplines, such as attorneys, wealth advisors, and life insurance specialists. The theory goes as follows: these professional disciplines cannot possibly be the “Most Trusted Advisor” because life insurance specialists just want to sell life insurance, wealth advisors just want to obtain assets under management, and attorneys just want to draft documents and handle transactions. (By the way, many non-CPA advisors refer to CPAs as “bean counters.”)

I say hogwash. First, these professional service providers are equally as capable of becoming the “Most Trusted Advisor” as are CPAs, should they choose to use business models that are highly relevant to the client and the economy of the present and the future. Second, granting one’s profession a certain status, by excluding all other professions from that status because of reasons based in stereotypes, is both disingenuous as well as dangerous.

If CPAs want to become the “Most Trusted Advisor,” then I say CPAs must EARN that title.

So how can CPAs do this? They must first learn to shift their collective focus away from the past (preparing income tax returns and preparing financial statements) and toward the future. Being relevant in the economy of the present and the future means CPAs must be able to take historical data, and use it to help their clients make better sense of the future.

Examples of future-looking services include: business cash flow and profitability planning, business process attestation, business risk mitigation, real-time financial reporting, income tax planning, business succession planning, and family wealth transfer planning. These types of services possess true value, unlike commodities such as tax returns and financial statements.

Further, to be the “Most Trusted Advisor,” the CPA must develop relationships with complimentary professional service providers, to the following extent: the CPA MUST become surrounded by other resources, on a collaborative platform, such that the client of the CPA firm can come to the CPA to get any and every problem solved, not just those problems that are CPA-centric.

This means CPAs must become good at establishing, building, and maintaining relationships, all the while being able to check their egos at the door. This involves a much different skill set than what is required by “number crunching,” and should in fact aspire to a “servant leader” mentality.

CPAs are without questioned positioned to earn the title “Most Trusted Advisor.” But will the profession ever change its backwards-looking ways, to really earn and thus deserve this lofty moniker?